Monday, June 15, 2009

I think the Shimerdas lived a middle- to upper-class life before they moved to their country. They developed a sense of entitlement that definitely didn't leave Mrs Shimerda or Ambrosch. Those two really bug me. They did nothing to ease Mr Shimerda's homesickness, nor did they try to be friendly and loving to those around them. I think all they think about is money and how to get ahead.

I'm glad that Jim's grandparents moved to town. It's what they need since they're getting to an age where it will be harder for them to get to town when they need to, as well as keep up on the farm. I am not so sure it will be the best for Jim since he won't be required to work as hard or keep as busy.

Antonia is an interesting character. She tries so hard to be tough and impenetrable, but at the end of the day she still needs to have her cry out, like we saw with Jim. She is so determined to not look like she is weak and feminine because this is what she sees as the way to earn her mom and brother's respect. I think she is acting more manly more to prove to herself and others that she is amazing that way than to actually become that way. However, I also think that she will always be resilient and comfortable with working hard because of these experiences.

1 comment:

srf said...

Ambrosch and Mrs. Shimerda are really something. I also noticed how suspicious they are of others--like when Mrs. Shimerda tried to pump information out of Jim and then seemed to doubt the trustworthiness or soundness of the information. Really all she had to do was the ask the grandfather and he would have probably given her more advice and information than she ever wanted. It is just another reflection on her own character--she doesn't trust other people because she imagines what she might do if the situation were reversed.

Similarly with Ambrosch, because he has no feeling of friendship in him, he can't figure out how to make friends with his neighbors or even comprehend that they might want to be friends with him. But I also think he has a tough time and is overcompensating for knowing that he has to make the land work but that he knows nothing about farming and not a lot of English. I can see why he would come off as tough around his neighbors, but he is shooting himself in the foot so to speak.