I now know Willa Cather

I, too, felt Jim missed out on his chance for happiness. And although Antonia's life is difficult, she exudes contentment. Yeah, Jim missed the boat. But he has his memories, real or contrived. I am glad we read this book. I had never read a book by Willa Cather before, and now that I know her, I would certainly read another. Her use of language is a real treat. Good choice.